Skip to content ↓


The Responsibility Project®. Exploring what it means to do the right thing

Friday Feb 10


A Part of the Special Feature Responsible Sports

Is it right for coaches to yell at children under 10 during sports games?

11 Comments

April 1, 2010

17,741 Votes So Far:

or view results.


Share this short URL /// http://sharerp.com/7p

 


11 Comments

What do you think? Leave a comment

  • April 17, 2010 by Chris Cyr

    As more and more kids take to organized ball, a few things happen. First, kids lose the opportunity to just play the game for fun, because they love the game - without umpires, just pick up a bat and play. On the other hand, more kids today have the opportunity to be part of a team, to learn how to play the game, and build even more enjoyment of the game itself.

    This is where the role of the coach comes in. All parents and coaches must recognize that in each town, maybe 18 kids go on to play some level of high school ball. Let's keep it in perspective. So - a coach - the role is two-fold - to teach, to cheer, to support.

    Mistakes happen - in sports and in life. How does a coach feel when they make a mistake at work - and get yelled at. Mostly, it doesn't happen - there is a discussion - but yelling, not so much. In the end, when we learn to treat kids with respect, when we learn that mistakes happen, when we take those mistakes and turn them into teachable moments - everyone wins.

    Yelling - it has no place in youth sports. Unless it is to get someones attention - yelling at a kid does not teach the kid - the youth hears the yelling - not what is coming out of the coaches mouth.

    Learn to support our youth - be positive role models - turn mistakes into lessons - teach, support, grow the love of the game.

    Reply

    • December 5, 2011 by darius

      We are keeping the pacifer in the mouth of our youths way too long. Children should not be singled out or embarassed with hurtful intent but the world should not come crashing down because a coach raised their voice.

      Reply

    • January 19, 2012 by shelley

      Yelling is not a problem, sports can be loud and a yell may be needed. What is yelled could be an issue. Yell encouragement, yell direction, yell concern... but when a couch is belittling or humiliating a child, that couch needs to find a different outlet. Keep the bully away from our kids.

      Reply

  • May 27, 2010 by Coach John

    There is nothing wrong with yelling at a kid. Quit trying to baby them!

    Reply

    • June 2, 2010 by Pacopablo

      There is something wrong with yelling at a child: it is not how adults should act.

      The absence of yelling does not equate to babying a child.

      If you're not intelligent enough to motivate and teach a child responsibility for their actions, without resorting to yelling, then you are a lousy coach.

      I agree that there is no need to coddle a child and make excuses for lack of performance; however, there is also no need to yell.

      Reply

    • November 12, 2010 by nathalia davis

      Just think, your on your job and you enjoy your job, but yet your supervisor comes out of nowhere and starts yelling at you for no reason,just that he thinks you should tighten up. Dont forget your trying your best. Now a grown up can tolirate a little more than a child. Yelling at a child can set them back and cause them to dislike there most favorite thing in the world to do. So what ever you do unto others the same shall be done unto you.And be careful, that same child you may yell at just might be your next supervisor. God Bless you all and have a blessed day.

      Reply

    • March 16, 2011 by James

      Kids do need to know when they are doing something wrong to improve their situation. But if you yell at a child and it becomes a emotional feeling to the child for what they are not doing wrong , you can effect there whole life when it comes to their relationships and success through their subconscious mind.

      Reply

  • June 4, 2010 by Bartleby

    Sports fields are large, and one cannot be heard in the heat of a game unless one yells. Yelling to berate a child is not something that should usually be done, but yelling to be heard is not out of line at all.

    Yelling at a child can be appropriate if the child needs to have their attention brought to their behavior and how egregious it may be. For example, deliberately injuring another person would be grounds for yelling.

    -Bartleby

    Reply

  • July 26, 2010 by Scipio

    Really, some of them just need to man up. They need to accept that life is harsh and people yell at you for little to no reason in all aspects of life.

    Reply

  • July 26, 2010 by Richard Nibbler

    if the child is disturbing people in any way, SO WHAT IF HE GETS YELLED AT BY THE COACH! THATS WHAT COACHES DO! YELL!

    Reply

  • October 22, 2011 by jodi

    Let the kids keep their innocence. There is no rason to put pressure on them to perform well in sports at such an early age. Aren't their more important lessons to be learned like team work and good sportsmanship?

    Reply



Tell us what you think.

Let the world know what you think, but please do so responsibly. Comments are moderated and we will not post personal attacks, obscene language or inappropriate material, comments with links, or comments from people under the age of 18. If you have a question, check out our Comment Submission Guidelines.

why are we asking for this?

By clicking submit, you agree to our site’s Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.


Find More ///


Related ///

Youth Sports and Responsibility

How do sports help kids learn the value of doing the right thing? A special multi-part feature about what parents and coaches need to know to ensure a positive — and rewarding — experience for their student athletes.

Should siblings be allowed on the same team?

TED Talk: Gary Lauder

The venture capitalist’s brilliant idea for reducing traffic accidents: a new sign.

TED Talk: Gary Lauder

Teaching Gratitude

Rock star business school teacher Srikumar Rao offers a class that gives his students broader perspectives on their lives.

2099 Driving Game

Think you can win a race in the year 2099? Take our new futuristic game out for a spin.

2099 Driving Game

Missy Franklin, a Real Team Player

This swimmer’s love of the game means more than the money of going pro.




About Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual is a provider of auto, home, and life insurance for consumers, as well as risk and disability products and services for businesses. Because responsibility is integral to who we are, we also support a range of community service programs around issues like fire safety and responsible sports. Through the Liberty Mutual Foundation, we make grants to organizations that show low-income students a path to lifelong success through education, and agencies that provide immediate basic health and human services to the needy. To learn more about us, visit us at LibertyMutualGroup.com

© 2012 Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, 175 Berkeley Street, Boston, MA 02116